Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Robert C Dean's avatar

Thank you for this marvelous essay. I was particularly moved by Umberto Eco’s words on his library. I too have more books than I can sit down and read in my lifetime (I’m 78) but now I realize I have been reading them all along. Yesterday on impulse I read the first three pages of The Wealth of Nations. Will I read the remaining 897 pages? Probably not, and yet perhaps.

It also occurred to me that libraries are like gardens, and rarely survive the life of their builder. They are ephemeral yet beautiful and should be experienced as such.

Expand full comment
Ted Holzman's avatar

Really good essay! I found Baldwin's quote particularly compelling. But I wonder about your conclusion about "good taste". It seems to me that authors whose works t have persisted over centuries and millennia -- Homer, Cervantes, Shakespeare, Melville -- have touched on things that universally resonate with the human spirit. But there are more temporal and quotidian books that are powerful or funny or poignant in their time, in their country, in their zeitgeist, that certainly won't last as long as Moby Dick or Don Quixote. For myself, I know that many of these books aren't of the greatest value, but they still nourish something in my spirit. I think one sometimes needs a little chocolate along with his/her bread.

Expand full comment
15 more comments...

No posts